Watch Me (Shatter Me: The New Republic, #1) – A Glimpse at What Was and What Could Be
I have to admit, I approached Watch Me (Shatter Me: The New Republic, #1) by Tahereh Mafi with a blend of excitement and skepticism. Having loved the original Shatter Me series, I was eager yet anxious to see how this new chapter would unfold, especially with new protagonists and the beloved characters from the previous books. As I dove into this intriguing extension of the series, I found myself wandering through familiar territory, oscillating between delight and disappointment.
From the outset, Watch Me presents itself as a story of heavy gazes and unspoken tensions. Its title, after all, encapsulates the essence of Rosabelle and James exchanging looks more than words—a reality that became both amusing and frustrating as I immersed myself in their world. I mean, half the time, it felt like I was drowning in a sea of intense stares (and, let’s be real, probably a few eye-rolls!).
The book naturally divides itself into two distinct halves. The first half? Pure gold. Packed with humor, thanks to the delightful James, and thrilling stakes that kept me on my toes, I couldn’t help but relish every page. But the latter half spiraled into a tedious loop, dragging with repetitive content that left me questioning, “Where’s the fun in this?” The allure of anticipation faded as I recognized the predictability of the plot, resulting in a significant drop in my engagement—3.5 stars for the first half and a dire 1.5 for the second. Ouch.
Characterization is a hallmark of Mafi’s writing, but here, it felt like a mixed bag. James started strong—infused with wit and a unique blend of Kenji’s sass and Aaron’s depth. However, by the end, his naivety pushed me to the edge. I just couldn’t fathom his blind trust in Rosabelle, especially after she’d shown traits that screamed danger! And then there’s Rosabelle herself—a character I sympathized with but ultimately found to be a bore. This disconnect kept me from connecting with their chemistry, as their relationship felt more like insta-attraction than a meaningful connection. Even the internal dialogues could’ve used a sprinkle of personality!
Yet, let’s not forget the saving grace of this narrative: the original characters! Any scene featuring Aaron, Juliette, or Kenji felt like a heartfelt reunion. Aaron’s transition into a protective husband, and his dynamic with former friends like Kenji, made my heart flutter. I squeaked in excitement at every casual banter and poignant moment. When it comes to character dynamics, that original gang never misses—I’ve missed their banter!
Watch Me shines in its exploration of world-building and highlights intriguing questions about artificial intelligence and governance. Klaus, anyone? Talk about an interesting character! I felt drawn into the philosophical threads woven throughout, despite my frustrations with Rosabelle and James. The writing style remains accessible and fluid, something I appreciated even when the plot hit diminishing returns.
So, who might enjoy Watch Me? If you found solace in the original Shatter Me characters and can tolerate a somewhat uneven narrative with newer faces, definitely pick this one up! It can reignite your connection to Mafi’s world, even if this installment felt like a “watch and wait” scenario rather than a thrilling "shatter" experience.
Overall, this read served as a bittersweet reminder of the magic I fell in love with—while longing for the intensity and depth from past installments. Any chance we can swap James for more Aaron insights in the next book? Because, honestly, that dilf energy is unmatched.
Discover more about Watch Me (Shatter Me: The New Republic, #1) on GoodReads >>