Book Review: Wizard of Most Wicked Ways (Whimbrel House, #4) by Tamsyn Muir
Ever since I stepped foot in the enchanting realm of Whimbrel House, I found myself captivated by Tamsyn Muir’s masterful storytelling and memorable characters. With Wizard of Most Wicked Ways marking the fourth installment in the Whimbrel House series, I was eager to dive back into a world brimming with magic, complexity, and familiar faces. After reading the earlier books, returning felt like reuniting with old friends—though, of course, they’ve been through some serious trials!
Set in 1851, this book continues Merritt, Hulda, and Owein’s journeys, with new challenges that tug at heartstrings and test loyalties. The narrative beautifully weaves together the everyday struggles of family life on Blaugdone Island, particularly for Merritt and Hulda as they navigate parenting against the backdrop of growing tensions. Owein’s trajectory is especially compelling as he grapples with royal expectations and the reverberating impact of his decisions on his heart—a true coming-of-age tale for this young man, and a stark reminder of the implications such choices hold in a fantastical setting.
Muir’s writing is as enchanting as ever, with a prose style that draws you in, though I did feel the pacing was a bit off initially. The first 20% of the book meanders through internal musings and love dilemmas, creating a slower buildup that felt somewhat at odds with the more exhilarating previous installments. However, once Silas Hogwood makes his ominous return, the story picks up pace significantly, culminating in a nail-biting climax that had my heart racing! The confrontation felt vivid and cinematic—it was a spectacle that rivaled a blockbuster superhero movie.
Speaking of characters, how could I not gush over them? Owein’s maturation is a delight, transforming from a boy into a young man of conviction and depth. His growing complexity made me root for him more than ever, especially in critical moments where he defies expectations. Merritt and Hulda continue to resonate as a couple whose chemistry is palpable. Their organic growth as parents feels refreshingly genuine, while fan-favorite Beth and Baptiste add a comforting familiarity to the mix.
However, I did have some reservations. The inclusion of a love triangle felt somewhat contrived, and at times, it took away from the historical fantasy’s allure. This subplot, despite being a common trope, seemed more like a way to create tension than an organic development. With only two of the triangle’s three sides actively at play, it felt like an uneven emotional landscape that detracted from the gripping narrative.
Yet, the charm of Whimbrel House’s magic was undeniably present, intertwining beautifully with a more somber undertone. The stakes felt higher this time around, especially with young children involved—their innocence standing in stark contrast to the resurrected threat posed by Silas. Muir nails the concept of continuity well; the sense of time passing is palpable, and it’s gratifying to see how characters have changed realistically over four years.
As I closed the chapters on Wizard of Most Wicked Ways, a bittersweet feeling remained. While I eagerly anticipate the series’ conclusion in Lady of Uncanny Charms, I couldn’t help but wish for a slightly different approach to the subplot dynamics. This installment, though darker, beautifully sets the stage for the finale while leaving us with enough intrigue to ponder for a long time.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who has followed the Whimbrel saga, as it cements itself deeply in its predecessors’ legacy. If you enjoy historical fantasy that will tug at your heartstrings—bolstered by strong characters and a riveting plot—this book is for you! It may not be without its hiccups, but Muir’s storytelling always leaves me yearning for more, and isn’t that what a great book should do?
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.75 stars)
To experience the full magic, make sure to read the previous books in the series first.
Discover more about Wizard of Most Wicked Ways (Whimbrel House, #4) on GoodReads >>